Skip to content
Free shipping Canada-wide on $60+ Free local delivery in Peterborough, ON on $20+ Bundle pack — 30% off 5% back to the hands that harvest

Tea Comparisons

Switching from Coffee to Tea: What Actually Changes?

by Bhaskar Dahal 15 Sep 2024 0 comments

You're here because coffee isn't quite working any more. Maybe it's the jitters, maybe it's your stomach, or maybe three cups before noon has started to feel like a problem instead of a routine. Tea is the obvious thing to try, but it's fair to wonder whether it will really work.

This article won't just cheer for tea. It explains what will change if you switch, what won't, and how to find out whether tea suits you without buying a 100g bag of something you might not like. The most practical way to test it is the Tea Sampler Kit ($30 CAD): 10 single-origin teas, enough to try every style before you decide.

The Caffeine Question

Every coffee drinker's first worry is the same: will I get enough caffeine?

Honestly, you'll get less, but it works better.

Drink Caffeine (mg per 240 mL)
Brewed coffee 80 to 120 mg
Espresso (1 shot) 60 to 75 mg
Black tea (loose leaf) 40 to 70 mg
Oolong tea 30 to 50 mg
Green tea 25 to 40 mg
White tea 15 to 30 mg

Black tea has roughly half to two-thirds the caffeine of filter coffee. There is an adjustment period: in the first week, some people feel noticeably less wired, especially if they were drinking three or four coffees a day. It passes as your adenosine receptors readjust over one to two weeks. After that, most people find a strong black tea gives them enough steady morning energy, without coffee's usual spike and crash.

Why Tea Energy Feels Different: L-Theanine

Tea contains an amino acid called L-theanine, which coffee doesn't have at all. L-theanine increases alpha brain wave activity, the state linked to focused, relaxed alertness, and changes the way caffeine is absorbed. The energy comes on more slowly, lasts longer, and doesn't tip into anxiety the way coffee can.

Research published in Nutritional Neuroscience found that L-theanine with caffeine improves sustained attention, memory, and reaction time more than caffeine alone. That's the main reason most people who switch from coffee to tea say they feel less jittery and don't get an afternoon crash.

High-altitude whole-leaf teas have more L-theanine than commodity teas. Our teas are grown at 5,000 to 7,000 ft in the Himalayan highlands of Ilam and Taplejung, where slow growth in cool mountain air builds both flavour and L-theanine, so the calm clarity is stronger than anything you'll get from a standard tea bag.

What About Your Stomach?

Coffee has a pH of around 5. It's mildly acidic and a common cause of acid reflux and stomach discomfort. Loose leaf black tea has a pH closer to 6 to 7, so it's much gentler on the digestive system. Many people who can't drink coffee any more because of stomach problems find they're fine with loose leaf tea.

High-altitude teas are gentler still. Grown at 5,000 to 7,000 ft, where the leaves develop slowly, our black teas have fewer tannins and no bitterness, so you can drink them without milk and without that coated-stomach feeling afterwards.

Will You Miss the Taste of Coffee?

To be honest, tea doesn't taste like coffee. If what you want is the dark, roasted bitterness of espresso, no tea will replace it. Tea has its own flavours, malty, muscatel, floral, earthy, vegetal, and none of them is "coffee".

What does carry over is the warmth, the ritual, and the cup in your hand that tells you the day has started. And a really good cup, like a properly brewed Gold Black Tea with its clean malt and caramel notes, is satisfying in its own right.

The bitterness that puts many people off tea comes almost entirely from cheap tea, boiling water, or over-steeping. Our black teas are grown at 5,000 to 7,000 ft in Ilam and Taplejung, where altitude and slow growth naturally give leaves with no bitterness. Steep them at 90 to 95°C for 3 minutes and you'll get a clean, full, satisfying cup.

The Easiest Way to Make the Switch

The biggest mistake people make is buying one tea and deciding all tea is like that. Tea varies enormously. A black tea from Taplejung at 7,000 ft tastes nothing like a green tea from Ilam at 5,500 ft, and neither tastes like a white tea from the same farm.

The Tea Sampler Kit ($30 CAD) is the sensible place to start: ten teas covering black, green, white, and oolong, 5g each, enough for two or three cups of each. Within two weeks you'll know which type suits your mornings.

For coffee drinkers, by coffee style:

  • Dark black coffee, no milk: Start with Special Black Tea (Theba Black) from Pathibhara Tea Estate, Taplejung, 6,000 ft. Dark chocolate, dried plum, pine resin. The boldest, most structured tea we sell.
  • Milky coffee, cappuccino, latte: Gold Black Tea from Farmers Tea Co, Ilam, 5,500 ft, grown on a certified organic farm. Smooth malt and caramel. Good with milk and excellent on its own.
  • Light-roast specialty coffee with fruity notes: Muscatel Black Tea from Norling Specialty Tea, Ilam, which is in the process of organic certification. Honey-grape, dried apricot, long finish. The most complex tea we sell.
  • Coffee drinkers with stomach trouble: Organic Light Green Tea from Farmers Tea Co, Ilam, 5,500 ft, grown on a certified organic farm. Low in acidity, gentle, and easy to digest.

The Cost

A 25g bag of our black tea ($10) makes 12 to 15 cups, roughly $0.67 to $0.83 a cup for single-origin Himalayan tea, against $3 to $5 a cup at a specialty coffee shop. Our largest bags (180g, $44 to $50) work out to well under $0.50 a cup. Loose leaf tea is one of the cheapest good-quality drinks there is.

Start Here: 10 Teas for $30, Shipped Across Canada, the USA, and Select Regions Around the Globe

The Tea Sampler Kit ($30) includes all four of our black teas, two greens, two whites, and two oolongs. It's the easiest way to find your morning tea before buying a full bag.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does it take to adjust after switching from coffee to tea?

Most people adjust within one to two weeks. The first few days can feel like less caffeine, because tea does give you about half as much as coffee. By the second week your body has readjusted, and most people say their energy feels normal, often with fewer jitters than on coffee. Going gradually helps: replace one coffee at a time instead of stopping all at once.

Will one cup of black tea give me enough energy to replace my morning coffee?

For many people, yes, especially if you brew it strong (1.5 tsp loose leaf per cup, 90 to 95°C, 3 to 4 minutes). Our black teas are grown at high altitude, where L-theanine is more concentrated, so the energy is steady, without coffee's spike and crash. If you need more of a kick at first, drink more: two mugs of black tea in the morning is common and completely fine.

What tea is closest to coffee for a coffee drinker?

Strong black teas are the closest: bold, warming, and satisfying on their own. Of our teas, Special Black Tea (Theba Black) from Pathibhara Tea Estate in Taplejung (6,000 ft) is the most structured and robust, and Ruby Black Tea from Sandakphu Tea Estate (5,000 to 6,000 ft) is full-bodied and dark. Neither tastes like coffee, but both feel like a serious morning drink.

Why do I feel calmer on tea than coffee even though both have caffeine?

L-theanine. This amino acid in tea crosses the blood-brain barrier and increases alpha brain wave activity, the state of relaxed, focused alertness. It changes how caffeine is absorbed, smoothing the peak and making the effect last longer. Coffee gives you caffeine as a sharp spike, while tea gives it as a long, gentle curve. High-altitude whole-leaf teas have more L-theanine than commodity teas, which is why ours feel noticeably more grounding than supermarket tea bags.

Related Reading

Prev post
Next post

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Thanks for subscribing!

This email has been registered!

Shop the look

Choose options

Edit option
Back In Stock Notification

Choose options

this is just a warning
Login
Shopping cart
0 items